Tom Morris



2009.10.28

  No. 1009 

Chronicle of Higher Education publish Romano piece on Heidegger... 2009-10-28T19:56:34ZPermalink

...and the (philosophical) world groans in frustration. Brian Leiter gives it a solid trouncing.

I am always astounded by the dull refrain of "Nazi! Nazi! Nazi!". Yes, well done, you've spotted the absolutely fucking obvious. Here, have a cookie. Is that really the best you can do? Shout ad hominems about Nazism? Okay then. I'm agnostic on the question of whether or not Heidegger has anything useful to say. I've actually got Hubert L. Dreyfus' Being in the World out from the library now and am using it to plough through Heidegger. But if I simply doggedly refused to read Heidegger because of his politics, that'd be pretty stupid.

He's claiming that Heidegger is to Nazism as Rawls is to liberalism. Because Rawls, in his defence of liberalism, spent a lot of time talking about ontology, Vorhandenheit, the phenomenal character of Dasein and so on. Knock hells bells out of his ontology, but to dodge ontology or aesthetics because of politics is ridiculous. Read Heidegger in spite of Nazism. Or follow Faye, Romano et al. and just ban Heidegger - empty the libraries of the world of Heidegger, expel him from the curriculum and burn the commentaries. Maybe we could set up a committee to inquire into the ideological purity of those teaching Heidegger. That'll really show those fascists how to be a good liberal...

Links from del.icio.us

Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus


Tom Morris 9f4907d871750fd4c9b9bad7086701b51d6abd10 bd9f81a05283ed85e699175ed057b4a497f20b77 802c68123e12bf69d99a25a87cef360f18813fe4
Currently in: East Sussex, England
Usually in: East Sussex, United Kingdom
AIM: tommorris
YIM: tom.morris

I am a , an , like to code in and (and Java, but let’s not talk about that), and noodle about with and the .

I have an MA in philosophy from Heythrop College, University of London. My philosophical interests are in analytic metaphysics, ontology, modality, the work of , , , and . I have a strange, unfulfilled interest in . I’ve been influenced by Gadamer, by , , and .

Musically, I like jazz fusion, soul and P-Funk. My musical nirvana would be a mixture of Beethoven, Miles Davis and George Clinton topped with a side-serving of Erykah, Jill and Angie.

I also write for the Citizendium, an online encyclopedia project. If you know about stuff, you should join in. I occasionally produce audio recordings for The Pod Delusion.

Elsewhere:

  • GPG Key
  • del.icio.us
  • Flickr
  • Twitter
  • Jaiku
  • LinkedIn
  • ma.gnolia
  • blip.tv
  • upcoming.org
  • MetaFilter
  • LiveJournal
  • CiteULike
  • Technorati Profile

RSS Feed Subscribe:

RDF

« October 2009 »
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

View in month context

On this day in: 2006 2007