2008.07.13

The Dewey Decimal System: some modest suggestions 2008-07-13T14:39:11ZTitled entry permalink

I really dislike the Dewey Decimal System. I used to think it was a brilliant system, but I've spent too many years in well-organised scholarly libraries (my college library uses Library of Congress classmarks and a home-brewed classification system) and gotten attracted to non-Dewey systems. My local public libraries use Dewey, and it is constantly irritating to me.

Currently, the 1xx region is for "Philosophy and psychology", but within that it's a mess. Psychology (15x) and "Paranormal phenomena" (13x) stick out like sore thumbs. There's an easy way to fix this. Move them to the end of the 1xx range - have Psychology as 18x and Paranormal phenomena as 19x, and shuffle all the philosophical topics down into the first seven ranges. If you were up for more radical change, then perhaps take Psychology out of the 1xx range and put it in the 3xx range - the social sciences. You could do that by compressing 35x and 36x.

In my local public library, there are a bunch of books on philosophical topics, but they are punctured with large amounts of cod psychology (of the Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus type) and paranormal claptrap. The Dewey system's 1xx range was probably fine for an age of Spiritualism and Phrenology (the latter getting it's own third-level category: 139) but in times where the cultish nonsenses are far more political and explicitly religious, the placement of 13x really does stand out. Similarly, now that psychology flourishes itself as a science, rather than as something of a latch-on to philosophy, it seems very strange to have the two mixed together.

This applies just as much to Library of Congress though - BF (Psychology) sticks out like a sore thumb in the B category. For religious topics, I'm a big fan of how LC do it though, and I could probably tell you down to a pretty good guess where you'd find stuff in the latter part of the B range.

In the end, it kind of makes you want to do it how some German libraries do it - have no categorisation scheme, and just put the books on the shelf based on publication date. Bring on the Semantic Web!

 

Login with your OpenID:
Le Web '08, Paris, December 9th and 10th, Register Now! 20% off.
No. 835
Tom Morris
Currently in: East Sussex, England
Usually in: East Sussex, United Kingdom
AIM: tommorris
YIM: tom.morris

I am a , an , like to code in and noodle about with and the . I also have a BA in philosophy from London, and am studying for an MA. My philosophical interests are in Victorian-era German philosophy, Kierkegaard, Robert Nozick, hermeneutics and current approaches to the demarcation problem in the philosophy of science. Musically, I like jazz fusion, soul and P-Funk. My musical nirvana would be a mixture of Beethoven, Miles Davis and George Clinton topped with a side-serving of Erykah, Jill and Angie.

I also write for the Citizendium, an online encyclopedia project. If you know about stuff, you should join in.

Elsewhere:

  • GPG Key
  • del.icio.us
  • Flickr
  • Twitter
  • digg
  • Jaiku
  • LinkedIn
  • ma.gnolia
  • blip.tv
  • upcoming.org
  • MetaFilter
  • LiveJournal
  • CiteULike
  • Technorati Profile

RSS Feed Subscribe:

RDF

« July 2008 »
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031 

View in month context

On this day in: 2006 2007