2007.05.30

Sallyy Satel on De Grote Donorshow: "It's crazy alright. And, yes, sick and shocking. But despite my discomfort, I'm for it. Sensationalism is a powerful way to call attention to the desperate shortage of kidneys and to the tens of thousands of needless deaths each year that occur all over the world because not enough altruistic donors step forward." 2007-05-30T14:20:03ZUntitled entry permalink

Cut the crap 2007-05-30T12:56:31ZTitled entry permalink

BBC News and The Independent report on a Dutch woman who is donating a kidney in a reality TV show, and contestants compete in order to get the kidney.

And, of course, the moralists are out saying that it's immoral.

Quite why is not explained.

If you want to sell your kidneys or let people compete for them on a reality TV show, I think that's absolutely fine.

You own your own body and should be able to do with it as you like. Now, the idea of people competing for a kidney may seem fairly disgusting, and, if I lived in Holland, it would be unlikely that I would watch this show - but I think it's fine that people want to do it.

If people had the option of donating organs under their own terms (whether it be selling them or setting up a reality TV show and getting people to compete for them), it may mean that more people will donate organs. That is the only moral consideration, as far as I am concerned.

That people might want to make money from their kidneys should not concern us. If we allow people to make money from their labour, their image and their sperm and ova, I think we really ought to allow people to do what they want with their organs.

Comments | TrackBack

 

Login with your OpenID:
No. 575
Tom Morris
Currently in: Greater London, England
Usually in: East Sussex, United Kingdom
AIM: tommorris
YIM: tom.morris

I am a , an , like to code in and noodle about with and the . I also have a BA in philosophy from London, and am in preparation for an MA. My philosophical interests are in Victorian-era German philosophy, Kierkegaard, Robert Nozick, hermeneutics and current approaches to the demarcation problem in the philosophy of science. Musically, I like jazz fusion, soul and P-Funk. My musical nirvana would be a mixture of Beethoven, Miles Davis and George Clinton topped with a side-serving of Erykah, Jill and Angie.

Elsewhere:

  • GPG Key
  • del.icio.us
  • Flickr
  • Twitter
  • digg
  • Jaiku
  • LinkedIn
  • ma.gnolia
  • blip.tv
  • upcoming.org
  • MetaFilter
  • LiveJournal
  • CiteULike
  • Technorati Profile

RSS Feed Subscribe:

RDF

« May 2007 »
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031 

View in month context

On this day in: 2006